[Ordinary of the Mass]
[English Text]
[Latin Text]
I remember hearing this parable of the Pharisee and the
publican as a young boy and completely missing its meaning.
It seemed to be another one like the parable of the unjust steward who had
been squandering his master's goods. The Pharisee seemed to be doing good
things, while the publican didn't seem to be doing much of anything. I
guess the concept of “humility” is pretty much wasted on most young men ten
or twelve years of age. But it turns out that humility is one of the most
important concepts of our Catholic Faith, so let me explain the parable with
some background information.
Our Lord “sets up” this parable, as he often does, by
picking one character whom everyone expects to be the “good guy,” and
another whom everyone expects to be the “bad guy,” and then reversing those
roles. The Good Samaritan, for example, is a foreigner and an outcast from
Jewish society. The priest and the levite are supposedly pillars of that
society. But, as everyone knows, the Samaritan is the one who helps the man
injured by robbers after the priest and the levite cross the road to ignore
him.
In today's parable, the Pharisee is the supposed pillar
of society—he is a descendant of the Machabees, those men who fought
valiantly against the generals of Alexander the Great to restore the
observance of God's Law and God's worship in and around the Temple at
Jerusalem. The Pharisees of Jesus’ time still held their ancestors’
positions of leadership, but their zeal for God’s Law was more of a show to
gain the respect of those who saw them. The Law required Jewish men to wear
tassels on their garments, so the Pharisees wore very wide tassels, so that
they might be seen keeping the Law.
The Law required them to fast, so they disfigured their faces so that they
might be seen fasting.
In another Gospel passage, our Lord would say that “hypocrisy is the leaven
of the Pharisees.”
Nonetheless we read today that this Pharisee was boasting before God in the
Temple about how well he kept the Law, and how much better he was than other
men. He was almost telling God that He (God) was very lucky to have such an
upstanding follower. Given this perspective, it is easy to see why our Lord
said that the Pharisee left the Temple unjustified.
A publican is a tax collector—a Jew who worked for the
hated Roman occupational forces, extracting money from his fellow
Jews—“blood money,” must of them would have said. Our publican is obviously
the one everyone would expect to be the “bad guy” in the story. But the
point of our Lord's parable is not about good or bad deeds, but rather about
one's attitude towards God, and particularly about how one sees one’s self
in relation to God. Acknowledging one’s shortcomings puts one in far better
stead with God than does telling God how lucky He is to know such a splendid
devotee!
True humility is the opposite of false pride. The sin
of Adam and Eve was the false pride given to them by the devil—that they
believed that they would “be like gods” if they ate the forbidden fruit.
The desire to be one's own god is certainly worse than anything the Pharisee
could have done. Most of us don't aspire to be gods—most of us are content
with just being “better than the other guy.”
But thinking that we are “better than the other guy” is
similarly false pride. We are all God's children, and in His eyes no one is
more precious than another. Look at the damage that results from thinking
that we are, indeed, “better than the other guy.” If I really think I am
better than my neighbor, what is there to keep me from thinking that I am
entitled to take his property if it suits me? If I really am better than
he, what is there to keep me from thinking that I can take his wife? Or,
for that matter, what is there to keep me from thinking I can take his
life? And, if I can think that I can take my neighbor's life, wife, and
property, have I not—at least in my own mind—made myself a god? Am I any
better than Adam in wanting to be god? Am I any better than this Pharisee
boasting before God? Certainly, if I make myself out to be a god, I will be
far less in God's opinion—and it is God's opinion that counts—I would be far
less than this publican who felt not worthy even to raise his eyes to
heaven. In this context it is plain to see how “he who exalts himself will
be humbled.”
But, if I can take but few more minutes, I would like
to point out that our Lord was in no way minimizing the importance of doing
good. We meet another publican, one named Zachæus, in another account, in
the very next chapter of Saint Luke’s Gospel.
It is read just about every time we celebrate Mass on the anniversary of the
dedication of a church. It is kind of a cute story, for Zachæus is a short
man, unable to see Jesus over the heads of the crowd in front of him—so what
does Zachæus do, but he climbs a tree along the route by which Jesus will
pass. On noticing him, Jesus was apparently impressed with Zachæus’ zeal
for seeing Him. So Jesus said to him: “Zachæus, make haste and come down;
for this day I must abide in thy house.” And Zachæus was very pleased to
extend his hospitality to our Lord, but some of the onlookers were critical:
“they murmured, saying, that ‘He was gone to be a guest with a man that was
a sinner.’” So, not boasting, but just defending himself against the
accusations of the crowd, Zachæus explained to Jesus that he really wasn’t
all that bad: “Behold, Lord, the half of my goods I give to the poor; and if
I have wronged any man of any thing, I restore him fourfold.” This seemed
to satisfy Jesus, who responded: “This day is salvation come to this house,
because he also is a son of Abraham. For the Son of man is come to seek and
to save that which was lost.”
Both the Pharisee, and this second publican
recounted the good things that they did—and they were, if fact, good
things. The second publican, Zachæus, is approved by our Lord, while the
Pharisee is not. The difference is that the Pharisee felt self-important
and boasted about his wonderful deeds, while Zachæus was doing nothing more
than explaining that he was really trying to follow God’s law, and that even
though he wasn’t perfect, he had a few good things to demonstrate his good
faith.
Our Lord approved of both publicans—the one who merely
admitted his sinfulness, and the second who could honestly say that he was
trying to be good. The first publican, our Lord said, “went down into his
house justified.” Of the second, He said: “This day is salvation
come to this house.” There is an important difference between
justification and salvation. Justification makes us capable of
pleasing God and working out our salvation. Salvation is the final reward
of a just man’s good life on earth. The first publican was justified
by his faith and his humility; the second was working to be saved by
keeping God’s Law and by his good deeds. We must go and do likewise—the
“recipe” is very simple: mix faith, humility, the Commandments, and the
works of Mercy, and God will exalt you over all who boast about how
wonderful they are, and how much better they are than the next one.